3.1. Protein composition of the three-dimensional crystals
The phycobiliproteins of S. elongatus consist of a and b subunits.
For C-PC, the amino acid sequences have been derived from gene
sequencing (Swiss-Prot database primary accession numbers P50032
and P50033) and shown to have molecular masses of 17443 Da and
18186 Da respectively. In this study, the SDS-PAGE profile of
the sample used for the crystallization trials indicated both
a/b C-PC and A-PC to be present in the ~17 to 23 kDa apparent
molecular weight range. This protein band profile is shown in
Fig. 1A, where lane 1 is similar
to that described previously (Ducret, Muller et al., 1998). Several
trials containing 3D crystals, such as those shown in Fig. 1B,
were pooled and the crystals separated from the supernatant by
a brief centrifugation step. SDS-PAGE revealed that the crystals
were of C-phycocyanin (Fig. 1A, lane 2) and the supernatant contained
non-crystalline allophycocyanin (Fig. 1A, lane 3). No evidence
for any linker proteins was found.
3.2. Crystallization
The optimal crystallization conditions were found by a novel method
of separating the nucleation and growth phases of crystallization
(based on Saridakis and Chayen, 2000). Screening around conditions
that initially gave small, poor-quality crystals was performed
in order to establish a working phase diagram for the crystallization
of the protein. Dilutions across the super-solubility curve into
the metastable zone of the phase diagram were carried out by transferring
the cover-slips holding the hanging drops, previously incubated
with conditions normally giving many small crystals, over reservoirs
with concentrations that normally yielded clear drops. High quality
crystals measured at least 250 x 250 x 150 µm (Fig. 1B)
and were carried forward for X-ray diffraction studies.
3.3. Crystallographic results
Diffraction patterns from C-PC crystals (e.g. Fig. 2A) identified
the space group as R32 (No. 155) with unit-cell dimensions of
a = b = 187.99 Å and c = 60.54 Å. This c-cell edge
was very close to that of F. diplosiphon and C. caldarium, suggesting
similar packing. Assuming a molecular weight of 35.6 kDa per /
C-PC heterodimer, and one heterodimer per asymmetric unit, then
Vm = 2.89 Å3/Da, implying a solvent content occupying ~
42% of the total volume. Vm decreased to 2.81 Å3/Da on inclusion
of the 3 covalently linked chromophores. Diffraction was observed
beyond the 1.4 Å limit (Fig.
2A), with the data being reliable up to 1.45Å. Relevant
statistics are given in Table I. Crystallographic data have been
deposited with the RCSB structural database (http://www.rcsb.org)
under codes 1JBO for the co-ordinates and R1JBOSF for the structure
factors.
3.4. Quality of structure
The model was adjusted to match the published sequence (Swiss-Prot
database primary accession numbers P50032 and P50033). All the
changes were confirmed with electron density in the map calculated
at 1.45Å, including the post-translationally modified side
chain of -Asn72, which was linked to the chromophore via an extra
methylene group. The sequence numbering adopted for F. diplosiphon
(1CPC) was retained for ease of comparison, i.e. with two gaps
in the -chain (between positions 140 & 143, and 150 &
161) and one in the -chain (72 & 75). Difference density maps
were used to locate the ordered solvent molecules, which were
included in the refinement. No density could be seen in a continuous
volume to suggest the presence of any linker protein. The contents
of the asymmetric unit are detailed in Fig. 2B. The Ramachandran
plot (not shown) indicates that residue Thr77 of chain B falls
outside the favored region of the chart as discussed previously
(Schirmer et al., 1987). An inspection of the model and electron
density shows good match and high quality (see Fig.3). There is
a close contact, 3.06Å, between the main-chain amide N and
the 3-fold symmetry generated -84 chromophore. This appears to
be a common feature in all C-phycocyanins, involved in locking
a trimer rigidly, and possibly playing a part in the fine-tuning
of the absorption and charge distribution properties of the protein.
3.5. Chromophores
The electron density around the three chromophores is shown in
Fig. 3. All are covalently attached to the protein via cysteines
-84, -84 and -155, denoted as CYC1, CYC2 and CYC3 respectively
(see also Fig. 2B). In the case of CYC2 an extra methylene allows
a linkage with -Asn72. The positions of -84 and -84 are reminiscent
of the heme binding sites of myoglobin, with the thio-ether bonds
having the R stereo-isomer conformation. The -155 binding site
is located in a short insertion loop not found in the -subunit.
Its thio-ether bond has the S stereo-isomer conformation. All
3 tetrapyrroles display Z configuration on the D ring. These features
are consistent with those found for the 1.66 Å C-phycocyanin
of F. diplosiphon (1CPC) and the 1.65 Å C-phycocyanin of
C. caldarium structure (PDB code 1PHN). However, a least squares
comparison between the chromophores reveals differences within
the C-phycocyanin structures (see
Fig. 3). The CYC1 chromophore is essentially identical in
all 3 organisms (see Fig. 3A/D/G), but this is not true for CYC2
or CYC3. Although ring D of the CYC2 chromophore has a similar
position in S. elongatus and F. diplosiphon, it differs in C.
caldarium. In the latter, ring D is displaced more into the cavity
of the protein as compared with S. elongatus and F. diplosiphon.
The displacement is in the region of 1.9 Å and does not
involve a change in its plane (see Fig. 3B/E/H). This seems to
result from a partial unwinding of the -helix from the 105-115
region in C. caldarium (Stec et al., 1999). In contrast, ring
D of CYC3 of S. elongatus is the same as that of C. caldarium
and differs considerably from F. diplosiphon (see Fig. 3C/F/I).
The difference involves a rotation such that the two dihedral
angles between the C and D rings change by ~75 and 20 degrees.
This structural difference is likely to reflect the different
packing arrangement at the interface between the trimers, due
to a lack of conservation of amino acid sequences (Adir et al.,
2001).
3.6. Oligomerization and distances between chromophores
In the / heterodimer, the separation and geometry of the three
chromophores allows only weak excitonic coupling. However, in
the phycobilisome and also in the crystal, the / subunits oligomerize
to form a hexamer consisting of two ab3 trimers (see
Fig.4). When 3 monomers are assembled into an ab3 trimer the
local environments around CYC1 and CYC2 chromophores change considerably.
In the monomer, the distance between these two chromophores is
~50 Å based on the centers of gravity of the conjugated
portions of the chromophores. In the case of the trimer, the distance
between the adjacent CYC1/CYC2 reduces to 21.0 Å, facilitating
a stronger excitonic interaction between them (see
Table 2). For inter-chromophore distances within the hexamer,
energy transfer is also favored between these chromophores to
such an extent that we have calculated one of the highest transfer
rates observed for such a protein, 236.4 ns-1. Furthermore, in
the hexamer the CYC3 chromophores are close enough to permit efficient
coupling, although this is less favorable compared to those within
each trimer.